My New Favorite, Night Owl's Eatery!

by Alyssa Reinbolt
(Venice, FL)

In retirement central here in Venice, FL is an incredible family owned and operated joint, Night Owl's Eatery. Betty Anne is the owner and culinary genius behind the dishes being served. She is an incredible woman with a sense for good comfort food.

On a whim and searching for late night comfort food, I saw the bright lights surrounding the Night Owl Eatery and pulled in. I had heard so many wonderful things about them, and figured it was time to try them for myself.

I was greeted as soon as I walked in the door (very cheerfully for the midnight hour) and asked if it was my first time. When I confirmed it was, she immediately started suggesting items and telling me their specialties. I felt right at home, like talking to a friend.

We got the regular Cheesesteak sandwich with their homemade cheese sauce, a Little Owl sandwich (I ordered mine without the chili), the Fried Mac & Cheese, and Fried Oreos for dessert, all to go.

Everything is made from scratch and made to order, so while I waited, I was able to chat with the owners (who are very passionate about their business!) and learned a lot! They are a family owned and operated business, with a play kitchen tucked in the corner for their adorable granddaughter to play with when she visits. (She was there tonight! Such a sweetheart!)

They get their bread from a local bakery made fresh daily, nothing is ever frozen, and all of their sauces are made from scratch. (I got one of each, and personally think they need to bottle it and sell it... Especially their version of Ranch, super thick and flavorful)

There was not one bite tonight that didn't give me a tiny "foodgasm". Everything was delicious!

* The Fried Mac N Cheese balls were HUGE (think of a softball filled with mac and cheese and then wrapped in a crispy blanket of awesome) and filled with so much cheesy goodness, my husband and I fought over who would get the last one (he won).

* The Cheesesteak is made with REAL prime rib, (not steakums like sooo many places use) and a glorious cheese sauce oozing through it.

* The Little Owl... I didn't even know where to start with the sandwich, so instead, I picked it apart. Chicken tenders, angus beef burger, french fries, onion straws, cheese sauce and bacon. Chicken tenders were seasoned well, and paired perfectly with their house made BBQ sauce and house made honey mustard. Onion Straws and Fries were perfectly crisp, and the burger was juicy and flavorful. Top it all off with bacon and cheese... It was heaven.

*Fried Oreos... I have always seen it, but have never tried it. I loved watching her batter and fry them right there. Everything is super fresh!

Trust me, this is the kind of place you WANT to go to.

Alyssa Reinbolt
Venice, FL

(Publisher's Note: They are open: Tues-Thurs: 6 p.m. - 2 a.m., Fri-Sat: 6 p.m. - 3 a.m. Their address is 2045 Tamiami Trail South, Venice, FL)

Click here to post comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Sarasota Dining – Your reviews and recommendations.


Site Sponsors




Discovery Cove

Featured Pages

Sarasota Fourth of July right column promo








Looking For a Hot Time After Dinner?
Check Out Our
Sarasota Bars and Clubs Guide



What other Web Visitors are Saying....

"John, your site is excellent! I am coming home from Afghanistan in 2 weeks and discussed with my wife where to go when I get home. We looked from Winter Haven to Tarpon Springs. This site made the choice for us. You have all the information we need in a perfect format. You have set the bar very high." -- David D, Florida

"Just stumbled upon your website and thought I'd send you a shout out. The site is marvelous. My girlfriend and I are paying a visit to Sarasota. It's one thing to hear good things on the Travel Channel; it's another to hear from a real person with real opinions. Thanks for all the info!" -- Brad, Michigan, US

"I just wanted to let you know I thoroughly enjoy reading what you have to say about Sarasota and the fun things to do here. I just recently moved to Sarasota and I am still looking for things to do. I find your site to be very helpful. Thank you for all the work you put into this site, for all of us to enjoy." -- Donna P, Sarasota, FL

"Wow! What a great way to represent our community! I love your site! I can look on here and see what's happening! And we know, there is ALWAYS something happening in Sarasota!" -- Heather P, Sarasota, FL

"Very glad I found your website.....this is a great website...will use it often & let friends know about it."  -- Jayne S, Bradenton, FL

"As a visitor to Siesta Key from the UK, I would just like to say what an excellent source of information your website is. Thanks & please keep it up" -- Chris M, United Kingdom

"Thank you for a great website. Keep up the great work!" -- Carole W, Newburgh, NY

"Cool site" -- Pat W, Massachusetts