Mattisons City Grille in Downtown Sarasota

Mattisons City Grille in Downtown Sarasota is one of several local eateries owned by local celebrity and executive Chef Paul Mattison.

The Mattisons location in downtown Sarasota is an open air, under roof, dining room with a bar, live music(evenings), and a menu with numerous options with dishes that include American, Mediterranean, Asian, Caribbean, and Italian cuisines.

As I've written elsewhere in my restaurant reviews I tend to go out to dine in "off season" when I can walk in and be seated virtually immediately. This was a late Friday in July with outside temperatures about 94 degrees so there were fans all over the room keeping the air moving and it wasn't uncomfortable.

Remember, this is basically an outdoor restaurant but with a roof over it. So, seating was prompt for me a buddy who turned out for lunch at about 1 p.m.

Mattisons City Grille

Drinks came quickly (Yeungling drafts $7) along with menus and the decision making process began.

My buddy, Steve, chose Fish Tacos ($15) and I selected a Turkey Wrap ($17) that sounded delicious: Swiss cheese / tomato cherry wood bacon / buttermilk ranch / avocado / mixed greens

I thought the prices were somewhat high for a lunch menu but I also realized that we were dining in downtown Sarasota with its high commercial properly taxes; and with the inflation of the past couple of years everything, everywhere has increased in price.

Mattisons City Grille

So it was: A Turky Wrap and Fish Tacos.

My Turkey Wrap came with 2 side dishes. I selected a house salad and French fries.

Both orders showed up pretty quickly and it was a good thing because I was hungry now. The fresh house salad with spring greens and ranch dressing was cool and refreshing and hit the spot.

The Turkey Wrap came with a nice buttermilk ranch sauce in it and the fries were crispy, seasoned and tasty. Very good fries.

It worked together fine and there was music plying from a music service of some kind, no live music until later.

The overall menu is quite varied and includes a BBQ Beef Brisket sandwich and a Caprese Foccacia that sounded delicious.

Something you don't see often on menus us Fried Green Tomatoes ($12) and Calamari ($14) both grace the list of appetizers at this writing.

For lighter fare there's a soup and salad menu section with New England Clam Chowder and a Greek Salad with New Zealand Lamb Chops!

The Mattisons City Grille menu also features about a dozen Lunch/Brunch items from a Mediterranean Frittata and Stuffed French Toast to a Pork Belly Rice Bowl and Fish & Chips.

Also, at the time of this review, on their Lunch & Brunch menu you can fiind a Steak & Eggs Bowl which is marinated bistro steak / fried egg / caramelized onions / cheesy scallion potatoes / peppers / mushroom gravy ($18)

What's your favorite Sarasota dining spot? What's the best meal you've had there? Let others know about your recommendations by writing your own Sarasota Dining Review. Share your favorite now!

There's also a dessert menu with Key Lime Pie and brunch cocktails are also offered including Mimosas and Bloody Marys. There's also Champaegne and Sparkling Wine from which to choose as well as white, red and and house wines plus draft beer as well as bottled and canned beer plus holiday and specialty cocktaills and soft drinks

Happy hour is daily from 3 p.m. - 7 p.m. and features house wine, well drinks and doemestic bottled beer for $4 (at this writing).

To sum it up, service was fast and friendly, however, it was "off season" and after the lunch hour when I was there, so during peak season it would be hard to predict how fast seating and service might be. 

It's a fine establishment to dine at and enjoy a cokctail at in the open air atmosphere or to enjoy live music with your friends or family in downtwon Sarasota, Florida. . 

Mattisons City Grille is definately a casual place to relax with a cocktail or lunch or dinner, jeans and shorts are common here.

Overall, I had a nice experience and lunch on a hot summer Sarasota afternoon. 

(Prices and menu items subject to change over time.)

LOCATION: downtown Sarasota right on Main Street at Lemon Avenue, 1 North Lemon Ave.

HOURS: Monday: 11:00am – 10:00pm. Tuesday – Thursday: 11:00am – 11:00pm. Friday: 11:00am – 12:00am. Saturday: 11:00am – 12:00am. Sunday: 11:00am – 10:00pm

Other Mattison’s locations include Mattisons Riverwalk Grille, Downtown Bradenton, 101 Riverfront Blvd #120, Bradenton, FL and Mattison’s Forty-One, 7275 S Tamiami Tr., Sarasota, FL.

Protected by Copyscape

From Mattisons City Grille to Sarasota Restaurants

Sarasota Activities

Escape-to-Sarasota-Florida Home

Enjoy this page? Please pay it forward. Here's how...

Would you prefer to share this page with others by linking to it?

  1. Click on the HTML link code below.
  2. Copy and paste it, adding a note of your own, into your blog, a Web page, forums, a blog comment, your Facebook account, or anywhere that someone would find this page valuable.

Site Sponsors




Discovery Cove

Featured Pages

Sarasota Fourth of July right column promo








Looking For a Hot Time After Dinner?
Check Out Our
Sarasota Bars and Clubs Guide



What other Web Visitors are Saying....

"John, your site is excellent! I am coming home from Afghanistan in 2 weeks and discussed with my wife where to go when I get home. We looked from Winter Haven to Tarpon Springs. This site made the choice for us. You have all the information we need in a perfect format. You have set the bar very high." -- David D, Florida

"Just stumbled upon your website and thought I'd send you a shout out. The site is marvelous. My girlfriend and I are paying a visit to Sarasota. It's one thing to hear good things on the Travel Channel; it's another to hear from a real person with real opinions. Thanks for all the info!" -- Brad, Michigan, US

"I just wanted to let you know I thoroughly enjoy reading what you have to say about Sarasota and the fun things to do here. I just recently moved to Sarasota and I am still looking for things to do. I find your site to be very helpful. Thank you for all the work you put into this site, for all of us to enjoy." -- Donna P, Sarasota, FL

"Wow! What a great way to represent our community! I love your site! I can look on here and see what's happening! And we know, there is ALWAYS something happening in Sarasota!" -- Heather P, Sarasota, FL

"Very glad I found your website.....this is a great website...will use it often & let friends know about it."  -- Jayne S, Bradenton, FL

"As a visitor to Siesta Key from the UK, I would just like to say what an excellent source of information your website is. Thanks & please keep it up" -- Chris M, United Kingdom

"Thank you for a great website. Keep up the great work!" -- Carole W, Newburgh, NY

"Cool site" -- Pat W, Massachusetts