Turtles Restaurant on Little Sarasota Bay has been around since 1986 and with a spectacularly wide view of Little Sarasota Bay you can have a great view of the water from anywhere outside or inside this Sarasota restaurant on south Siesta Key.
They also provide a wide menu that includes everything from fresh Florida seafood to nightly specials that may include Prime Rib, Grouper specialties, Soft Shell Crabs, Filet Mignon and more.
Dining on the outside upper deck or lower open sky deck is magical and scenic as the sun goes down at Turtles Restaurant on Little Sarasota Bay.
On one visit here with family, who was in from out of town, we celebrated my mother’s birthday and everyone was thrilled with the seating location and great view of the bay as this is one of the few Sarasota restaurants with a premier water view. The great bay view and seating location helped to make it a festive occasion.
We were fortunate to have outdoor, lower deck seating and as it grew dark, looking out at the bay, the stars came out overhead, adding further to the ambient glow provided by the deck lights and ensuring that this would be a fine Sarasota dining experience.
I’ve dined at Turtles Restaurant on Little Sarasota Bay for both tasty lunches and delicious dinners. Let me fill you in on some of the tasty meals I’ve had here!
As you can see, the view of Little Sarasota Bay is spectacular. What better appetizer or accompaniment to lunch or dinner could you ask for? Except for, perhaps, some Mullet jumping out of the water or a Pelican diving into the bay for its own tasty meal as a little free entertainment!
One of my favorite dinners at Turtles Restaurant is Shrimp and Crab Au Gratin. This is a scrumptious casserole style dish; delicious shrimp and delicate crab meat, topped with cheese and baked in the oven. I’ve had this on several occasions and it’s always a special treat for me.
Another of the seafood menu items I’ve had the pleasure to dine on is Shrimp and Scallops Alex; shrimp and scallops in a nice creamy red sauce with tomatoes and mushrooms over linguine. It’s very good and filling.
If you’re a steak lover, Turtles Restaurant on Little Sarasota Bay has New York Strip on the menu, but Turtles also seems to have Prime Rib on “nightly special” often enough and at a lower price. So if I’m in the mood for steak, I’ll have a cut of their prime rib, done to order.
Tip: When your server asks if you’d like soup or salad with your lunch or dinner, ask for the soup, especially if you like Clam Chowder. It’s so good that you’ll wish (as I do) that the serving was a bit larger!
Or you can order a fresh garden salad, as either soup or salad
comes with dinner as well as fresh rolls, fresh vegetables and potatoes
Other items of interest on the dinner menu that look tempting include: Roast Long Island Duckling, Rack of Lamb, Fresh Florida Grouper, Lobster Alfredo, Baked Stuff Shrimp and North Atlantic Salmon Pasta, just to mention a few.
Something they instituted at Turtles on Little Sarasota Bay is that you can enjoy a Carafe of California Wine, sometimes included with dinner specials. Ask for details.
During our family gathering we went through two bottles as the wine we selected complimented well the entrées everyone ordered. There’s also full bar service available.
By the way, Turtles Restaurant features what they call “value meals” Monday through Sunday from 3:30 p.m. to 5:30 p.m. Some restaurants call this the “early bird” dinner menu.
The other nice thing about Turtles Restaurant on Little Sarasota Bay is its close proximity to Siesta Key’s Turtle Beach.
If you "time" your happy hour (3 p.m. - 6 p.m. daily) or dinner just right, you can take a short walk over to Turtle Beach on the gulf side of Siesta Key and watch an awe inspiring sunset, before or after dinner. This is one of the few Sarasota Florida Restaurants where you can do this, so it’s a nice “extra.”
There’s also a Sunday Brunch from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. but it is not an “all you can eat” style buffet brunch. You get your choice of brunch menu items for $8.99 and there’s a complimentary Mimosa, or Bloody Mary.
Turtles Restaurant on Little Sarasota Bay offers a wide array of menu selections, fast, friendly and professional service, delicious food and a spectacular view of the bay. It’s hard to top this experience.
Unfortunately they don't take reservations but do have something called "preferred seating for groups of 6 or more. (941) 346-2207.
Directions: Coming from Sarasota and U.S. Rt. 41, take U.S. Rt. 41 to Stickney Point Road, head west over the draw bridge and turn left at the first intersection, which is Midnight Pass Road. Follow Midnight Pass Road to the south end of Siesta Key and look for the Turtle Beach Marina on the left. 8875 Midnight Pass Rd.
By water: At Marker 48 on the Intercoastal Waterway, you can come by boat or kayak to Turtles on Little Sarasota Bay, tie up, and have a pleasing meal and experience.